2016 New York State Fair
   Grand Champion - Chastinet™
   Gold - Chastinet™

2016 American Cheese Society
   Gold - Chastinet™

2016 Cheese Makers Association (World Championships)
   Silver - Hot Wasabi Horseradish

2015 New York State Fair
   Gold - Chastinet™ 
   Gold - Jalapeno & Peppadew™ Cheddar 
   Award of Excellence - Aged Gouda 

2014 New York State Fair
   Grand Champion - Gouda 
   Gold - Grilled Bacon Cheeseburger 
   Award of Excellence - Bergenost™ 

2012 New York State Fair
   Award of Excellence - Bergenost™
   Award of Excellence - Smoked Jalapeno & Cayenne Cheddar

2011 New York State Fair
   Gold - Steakhouse Onion Cheddar \

 2010 New York State Fair
   Grand Champion - Jalapeno and Peppadew™ Cheddar 
   Gold - Jalapeno and Peppadew™ Cheddar
   Silver - Horseradish Cheddar

2010 Cheese Makers Association (World Championships)
   Gold - Jalapeno and Peppadew™ Cheddar
   4th-Place - Smoked Gouda and Bacon Cheddar
   4th-Place - Roasted Garlic Cheddar
   5th-Place - Horseradish Cheddar

2009 New York State Fair
   Gold - Picante Olive Sharp Italian Table Cheese
   Silver - French Herb Crusted Double Cream
   Award of Excellence - Bergenost™

2009 American Cheese Society
   Bronze - Scandanavian Swiss

2008 American Cheese Society
   Bronze - Strawberry Chardonnay™ Cheddar

2007 NASFT, Inc.
   Silver - Fire Roasted Tomato™ Cheddar
   Silver - Jalapeno and Peppadew™ Cheddar

2006 New York State Fair
   Grand Champion - Jalapeno and Peppadew™ Cheddar 
   Gold - Jalapeno and Peppadew™ Cheddar
   Silver - Aged Cheddar w/ Finger Lakes Champagne

2005 American Cheese Society
   Silver - Aged Cheddar with Peppadew™ Peppers

2005 New York State Fair
   Gold - AALBRUK™ Smoked Gouda
   Silver - Aged Cheddar with Peppadew™ Peppers
   Silver - Blue Bergenost™
   Award of Excellence - Extra Sharp Washed Curd Country Store Cheese
   Award of Excellence - Aged Cheddar with Finger Lakes Champagne

2005 World Dairy Expo Championship
   Silver - Aged Cheddar with Peppadew™ Peppers

2004 World Dairy Expo Championship
   Gold - Aged Cheddar with Peppadew™ Peppers

2004 Cheese Makers Association
   Silver - New York Sharp Pasteurized Process Cheddar

2004 New York State Fair
   Gold - Extra Sharp Washed Curd Country Store Cheese
   Gold - New York Sharp Pasteurized Process Cheese
   Silver - Aged Cheddar with Peppadew™ Peppers

2003 New York State Fair
   Silver - AALSBRUK™ Smoked Gouda

2002 New York State Fair
   Award of Excellence - Extra Sharp Washed Curd Country Store Cheese

2001 New York State Fair
   Medal of Honor Extra Sharp Washed Curd Country Store Cheese 

2000 New York State Fair
   Silver - Jalapeno and Cayenne Cheddar
   Award of Excellence - Extra Sharp Washed Curd Country Store Cheese

1999 New York State Fair
   Gold - Bergenost™
   Award of Excellence - Extra Sharp Washed Curd Country Store Cheese