Flavored Cheeses

 We guarantee that you will be delighted with our handcrafted cheeses. If you don't agree that they're the best you've ever tasted, simply mail in the reason, price, and proof of purchase (UPC label or cash register receipt) to us and we will give you a voucher for replacement!

Buffalo Wing Cheddar

Savory Garlic Buffalo Wing Cheddar

Champagne Cheddar

Steakhouse Onion Cheddar

Habanero/Jalapeno Cheddar

Horseradish Cheddar

Jalapeno/Cayenne Cheddar

Jalapeno/Peppadew Cheddar

Maple Cheddar


Maple/Bacon Cheddar


Peppadew Cheddar


Pepperoni Cheddar


Strawberry Chardonnay Cheddar


Roasted Garlic Cheddar


Wasabi Cheddar


Smoked Cheddar


Smoked Gouda w/ Bacon


Horseradish & Smoked Bacon



Smoked Gouda




Natural Smoked Jalapeno & Cayenne



Grilled Bacon Cheeseburger



Chipotle & Habanero Cheddar



Fresh Killer Dill Cheddar


Yancey's Fancy produces many of these flavors in a variety of sizes such as 43 lb. blocks and 10 lb. prints. For a complete list of available sizes please contact customer service.